Home > Arguments > Compare Counterarguments > Russia is a Space Power Threat

Compare Counterarguments

Russia is a Space Power Threat (1139)

Russia has a long history of space warfare technological and doctrinal development. They conducted a successful series of co-orbital anti-satellite weapons tests during the Cold War and could re-introduce this technology or sell it.
[ more ]
 

Russia is not a Space Power Threat (1325)

Russia does not presently possess either the technology or the motive to threaten U.S. space assets. While they did develop and test a co-orbital ASAT during the Cold War, they have no motivation to use it now or share the technology with other countries. Russia has also consistently advocated for a new agreement to limit space weapons. In addition, the entire Russian military space industry has contracted after the Cold War and they have been unable to maintain their basic military space functions, let alone ASATs.
[ more ]
 

Discuss this Counterargument Pair

Post a new message -- [First time here? Please read before posting]
Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:
 
 Please enter the numbers that appear in the box above:
Why do I have to do this?


 UBB-like code is enabled in this forum.