Spacedebate.org: U.S. Space Assets Vital

U.S. Space Assets Vital (1132)

The U.S. economy and military depend on the security of existing space assets.

[ more ]

Supporting Arguments

U.S. Military Power Depends on Existing Space Assets [1133]
U.S. Economy Depends on Existing Space Assets [1134]

U.S. Space Assets are not Vital (1284)

Space is not a critical center of gravity because many of the functions currently performed by existing space assets could be performed by ground-based or near-space technologies.

[ more ]

Supporting Arguments

U.S. Space Assets are not a Vulnerable Center of Gravity [1296]

Pick which argument is stronger [What criteria should I use?]

This argument is stronger.

Post a new message -- [First time here? Please read before posting]
Name:
Email:
Subject:
Message:

	Please enter the numbers that appear in the box above: Why do I have to do this?
	UBB-like code is enabled in this forum.

Compare Counterarguments

U.S. Space Assets Vital (1132)

U.S. Space Assets are not Vital (1284)

Discuss this Counterargument Pair