Home > Arguments > Foreign Space Assets Threaten U.S.

Foreign Space Assets Threaten U.S. (1148)

U.S. security is threatened by foreign imaging, surveillance, and reconnaissance satellites.

Keywords:

Can you improve on this argument text? Help develop this argument by editing and adding more information or click on one of the edit links below to add a counter, supporting, or related argument.

Flag this argument: [ What is this? ]

Supporting Arguments

[edit ]  [history ]

Counter Arguments

[edit ]  [history ] [compare ]

Parent Arguments

Related Arguments

[edit ]  [history ]

Evidence


Foreign Adversaries can Utilize Commercial Satellite Services that the U.S. will be Politically Unable to Disable
 
Attacking a commercially owned satellite, even one which is partially leased to or providing information to a belligerent's military, would be broadly equivalent to attacking neutral shipping in wartime. A conflict in which this became a regular practice would be comparable to the unrestricted submarine warfare of the world wars. (It also would represent a practical inconvenience for the United States given the reliance of its economy and military on commercial services.) The number of such services available may offer such redundancy as to make it impossible to totally deny a sophisticated enemy access, even after it has executed its initial strike. ( More ... )
Elhefnawy, Nader. "Four Myths About Space Power." Parameters. (Spring 2003): 124-32. [ 6 quotes ] [ page 124-5 ]

Gulf War Showed Threat Commercial Imagery Poses to U.S. Troops
 
The 1991 Persian Gulf War provided the first evidence of the growing danger commercial earth-imaging satellite systems posed to United States military operations. For the first time in history, military commanders recognized commercially available satellite images could deny their forces the element of surprise because images had become sharp enough to detect force deployments and movements. Since 1995 more than sixteen countries and multi-national consortia have put commercial satellite-imagery systems into service, half with image-quality better than eight meters, further raising the threat posed to American and allied forces.
Latchford, Stephen. Strategies for Defeating Commercial Imagery Systems. Maxwell Air Force Base, Alabama: USAF Center for Strategy and Technology, December 2005. [ 9 quotes ] [ page 1 ]